Commentary

The 2 cent bachelor’s degree

POSTED AT 10:48 PM ON Nov. 2, 2009 | PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (12)

Americans pay more out-of-pocket college expenses than almost any country on Earth. So how is it that students in France and Denmark, among others, go to school without paying a dime?

Because their governments work like they’re supposed to. 

But college doesn’t have to cost anything out-of-pocket here, either. If the state government would simply raise the state sales tax 1.93 percent, every single student in Indiana could go to college without paying a dime. It’s as simple as that. 

And because I’m a nerd, I can prove it.

Indiana has approximately 160,000 undergraduate students attending its public universities. Based on the cost of attending IU, I’ve estimated that $15,000 would more than cover the costs of one year of school at all of these schools for Indiana residents, with plenty of wiggle-room left over.

If the state guaranteed a maximum of $15,000 to each of Indiana’s graduating seniors, it would cost the state $2.4 billion annually, or 4.6 percent of the state’s current budget, to fulfill the guarantee.

Based on the expected generated revenue, by raising the state sales tax – currently set at 7 percent for counties outside of the Indianapolis metro-area – to 8.93 percent, the state would gain an extra $4.8 billion every two years on top of the current $12.57 billion it currently earns from sales tax revenue (a 27 percent increase).

Because the state budget covers two years, dividing the $4.8 billion figure in half will get you the exact amount necessary to give every Indiana high school student who matriculates to a public university in Indiana $15,000 per year to cover all college expenses – namely, $2.4 billion (as it was calculated above). 

It’s as simple as that.

Pay two more cents on every dollar’s worth of goods you purchase in the Hoosier state and you can go to college for free. Think that might motivate more kids to go to college? I certainly do. 

A university education is our right. I know, I know, in the United States we pay for our rights, like how we pay for our right not to die when we have medical problems, or how we pay for our right to get a free public high school education by buying high school textbooks. 

But it shouldn’t be that way, and it isn’t that way in the rest of the world. After all, if France can do it, then so can we. 

It is morally wrong that we have to bury ourselves in mountains of debt with usurious interest rates in order to pay for something that should and could easily be free. You shouldn’t have to pay to be here; the only reason you are is because your government has abdicated its responsibilities.

PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (12)





Name: *
Email: *
E-mail address will not be published.
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text
  *
 
 
All Comments  (12)

Posted by comprehensive reader at 10:50 AM on Nov 18, 2009 | Report this comment

I enjoyed reading the arguments against this article almost as much as I enjoyed reading the article. All the arguments show is that the writers: a. did not completely read the article, b. did not check the facts or do the math involved, and/or c., simple did not completely comprehend the focus of the article. I suppose the other option is that the writers of some of these comments also love spending money and hate giving other people opportunities...no way of knowing. Kudos, Mr. Ammerman.

Posted by not an idiot at 11:48 PM on Nov 04, 2009 | Report this comment

Wow dumbasses, way to actually read the article. It's clear you all skimmed the article and found "flaws" in it to use to attack the article. Let me clear up a few things for you. Firstly, he VERY clearly stated that $15,000 would be the amount for one year, not all four. Also, this is more than enough for the 160,000 undergraduate students in PUBLIC Indiana universities. Yes, there are far more universities in Indiana, but a number of those are private (Depauw, Butler, Notre Dame, etc.). You are all obviously as big of idiots as you accuse Zach of being. And "mandyAmanda", you spend a pretty absurd amount of time reading IDS articles for as much as you criticize them. Get a life.

Posted by mandyAmanda at 6:9 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

A lot of peopl ehave been piling on Mr Ammerman. As they should. This is a bad piece of writing. The IDS should be ashamed of publishing this. Ernie Pyle is crying from the grave. Let me add some more piling on.: This has to be the stupidest, dumbest, most moronic-est column i have seen in the IDS lately. And the IDS is where idiocy is the norm. Holy crapy this is a dumb idea. If the state payed for everyone's college education, I think the state should consider making students take real classes instead of whatever trash this author has been taking. Because obviously his teachers aren't teaching him basic critical thinking.

Posted by Ross Schumacher at 4:35 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

I do not understand how trash such as this gets published. A 2.7 % increase on sales tax would effectively end Indiana's economy.

Posted by Eline's Friend at 3:16 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

You're as entitled to a university education as I am to keeping my money. Keep writing articles like this - you only hurt your cause.

Posted by Brutus at 3:10 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

This might help you out for future articles: Spring 2010 ECON-E 202 INTRO TO MACROECONOMICS (3 CR) MW 5:45PM TR 8:00AM, 9:30AM, 1:00PM Good luck, it may be more challenging than polisci.

Posted by dumb at 1:13 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

And so, since a lot of people never make it past their first year, do they need to repay the money? I mean, you proposed money for EDUCATION. So if they drink themselves out of college, they should pay it back, right? Since they didn't get educated, correct? Also, if the 15,000 is indeed over the 4 year course (and what happens if it's 5 or 6 years? Keep paying while they are playing, makes sense) Anyways, if it is 4 years, you surely realize then that it is going to be 8% then right, coupled ontop of the already 9% sales tax in the Donut counties, Your proposal would bring indiana's economy to a screeching halt. Back to the drawing board mr. ammerman, try again.

Posted by Engel at 11:49 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

To be fair, I believe the 160,000 figure is the number of Indiana HS seniors each year. I don't think he is suggesting we should pay for everyone to come to IU from around the world. Also, I am assuming he means $15,000 per year, not $15,000 in total. Regardless, this article is just another in the line of useless liberal fantasies that continue to dig us deeper and deeper into debt at a national level. Thankfully in Indiana we have a Gov. who is committed to lowering the debt burden for us citizens. First off, a college education is not a right. Just because people want it does not make a thing a right. Second, college is not for everyone. After going to IU for 4 years, I can tell you there are plenty of people there who didn't deserve to be there/were wasting their time there. Third, this is not an efficient use of money. Right now anyone can go to college if they want by use of loans. I am financing my legal education 100% with loans. Sure it is a lot of debt, but at the end of the day I figured it would be worth the return on the investment. That is the same question people who cannot afford to go to college should ask themselves. In your purposed system, the tax payers will subsidize the education of people in majors where there are no jobs. I suppose your next government plan would be to just hike the sales tax up a few more percentage points to feed and shelter these college grads with no jobs. Fourth, you didn't consider that the tax rate-revenue relationship is not necessarily linear. It is not certain that this 2% increase will generate enough revenue as people decide to eat out less or not buy as many goods since the tax rate is higher. Overall, this would be a horrible idea.

Posted by 08 alum at 9:5 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

Your article is so flawed I don't even know where to start. A free education? Yet you only give 15,000 to each of the graduating indiana Seniors. Please clarify. $15,000 sure didn't pay off my 4 years, and are we talking highschool seniors or college seniors? You mention only 160,000 indiana university students, so I'll assume you mean college. Well, hate to break it to you, but that just opens up a whole 'nother box of worms. Secondly, there are more colleges in this state than just Indiana University schools, perhaps you should have calculated that into your figures. Thirdly, if school was indeed free, that 160,000 number all the sudden becomes 360,000, perhaps you should have calculated that into your figure. Fourthly, now I'm not going to give you a full on economics lesson, since it appears you lack basic math skills already. But at this point in time, your 2 cent raise on sales tax is already up to about 7 or 8 cents, now what do you think is gonna happen to someone living in Terre Haute, and they want to go buy a new big screen tv for $2000.00? They could buy it in indiana, and pay 2300 bucks (2k + 15% sales tax) or they could drive across to illinois and buy the same tv for less (as their state sales tax is less). Those state border counties will not contribute to the state sales tax as they once did, state revenues will drop, forcing overal states sales tax revenues to drop, and once again we will have to bump the tax another percent or two. I could go on and on, bottom line, is college isn't for everyone. There needs to be a combination of intelligence, and access to funds. Thats the bottom line, it's a little cold hearted, but let me ask you this, article writer: If everyone has a college degree, who is going to come pick up my trash on Monday mornings? Are you?

Posted by Drew at 8:50 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

A university education is not a right. Man up and take responsibility for yourself. No one owes you anything simply because you exist. I'll make a deal with you. I'll keep my money, you keep yours. I won't demand that the government take your money and give it to me and you do the same. Is this not fair?

Posted by nick at 7:45 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

Your 160,000 number is way off. The IU system has over 100,000 alone. Ivy tech over 120,000. Purdue over 70 or 80k in the system. Ball state over 20,000...I don't need to keep going.

Posted by Bob at 5:2 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

Would you value that education? College is not for everyone. College is a privilage earned by the sweat of your parents our the sweat of the individual who applies for scholarships and assumes the risk of investment in their own education. Quit sucking the life out of our society for your personnel gain. I really don't care if you get an education. However, I will care how you perform acedemically if I have to pay for your education. I will care how you apply your education post college and I will want you to pay the $60000 we spent on you back to the state for other pressing matters like eliminating Unions and usery taxes on industry that might want to set up in this great state.


Email

Your Name: *
Your Email: *  
To Email: *  
Subject: IDSnews.com | The 2 cent bachelor’s degree
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text



*