Commentary

Mud, mud everywhere

POSTED AT 10:52 PM ON Nov. 2, 2009 | PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (6)

It’s been two weeks since Victoria’s Secret descended upon Dunn Meadow and erected its stage for the Oct. 22 Girl Talk concert.

But I’m still upset.

Sure, the concert was great. Everyone I know who went had a great time, and it was really exciting to have a concert outside.

Granted, the concert also raised $5,000 for Middle Way house, and Victoria’s Secret put it on for no charge.

But we should have known better. As my economics professor once told me, nothing can ever be free. There are always costs associated with something, even if they are non-monetary ones.

And what was the great cost of last month’s Girl Talk concert? Dunn Meadow.
If you haven’t walked down Seventh Street lately, you might not know that there is a well of mud masquerading as Dunn Meadow.

It looks like California during the rainy season, or the third day of Woodstock – only less fun.

Victoria’s Secret agreed to pay for the damages to the field, but I say that’s not enough. Because winter is coming on quickly, whatever grass the company puts down in the field won’t start growing until March. That’s four months we will have to suffer with a pig hole for a gathering place.

I’m not the only one who is upset about this. Last week, someone erected a makeshift white sign in the middle of the mud pile. It called the desecration of the meadow an example of the destruction caused by giant corporations.

What’s more is that Dunn Meadow is a historic spot on campus, and to have half of it covered in mud disgraces that history.

Since 1963 when it was officially dubbed the assembling place for the campus, Dunn Meadow has hosted anti-war protests, memorial vigils and large gatherings of all sorts.

Dunn Meadow is supposed to belong to the students. It is supposed to be our place to relax on blankets, to throw Frisbees, to challenge administrations. It isn’t fair that one event has rendered our collective gathering spot out of commission until spring. 

I like the idea of having concerts outside, but the next time Union Board helps to sponsor an event in Dunn Meadow, they need to make sure we aren’t going to be paying interest on that concert for months to come.

Future events must be held to stringent rules so that we protect Dunn Meadow.
Any artist that contracts to play there should be required not to repair the damage afterward, but to make sure that this sort of damage doesn’t happen in the first place.
More careful planning could potentially have saved Dunn Meadow.

And if those requirements scare away some artists or make it so we have to have all of our concerts in the IU Auditorium, so be it. The history and heritage of that space is worth preserving.

Sacrificing Dunn Meadow for the better part of the school year is too high a price to pay for a “free concert.”

PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (6)





Name: *
Email: *
E-mail address will not be published.
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text
  *
 
 
All Comments  (6)

Posted by Happy Student at 10:39 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

I'm not sure what this columnist is trying to get it - yes, the concert did cause Dunn Meadow to turn into a giant pit of mud. First she points out that Dunn Meadow is supposed to be "an assembling place for students." Isn't that what this concert did? Assembled students? Over 5000 students showed up for the event - an impressive feat seeing as how we have a hard time getting that many students to show up to a FOOTBALL GAME. This event was one of the best IU has held in recent years, and I haven't heard of one person who hasn't enjoyed this event. Not only did this event provide a safe, fun way for students to relax and socialize, but it also raised $5000 for a charity. So I give you my sincerest apologies Erin Chapman for the mud. I'm sorry you cannot lay out during the next few winter months on the snow covered lawn. I'm sorry that you can't go to another area to throw a frisbee around. But really, stop your bitching and be grateful that we were able to host such a unique and fun event. And please take time to acknowledge the hours of work and planning that Union Boad, WIUX, and other organizations put into planning this wonderful event.

Posted by greg at 6:49 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

Throw concerts at the tailgate fields, I don't understand why that wasn't done in the first place.

Posted by Realism... at 6:45 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

No Amount of planning would have saved the field... They laid down plywood to drive on to try and protect the field, and you know what happened... The Plywood sank into the field and the mud was created... if you don't believe me, go out there and poke around in the mud I'm willing to bet there are still a few sheets of ply hidden in the mud... That Being said, IDS, please stop printing these stories about Dunn Meadow, we get it, there is a minority out there that is upset about dirt in a field...

Posted by Fuzzy McBunny at 2:22 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

I know!!! All I want to do in this 45 degree weather is lay out on a blanket in Dunn Meadow and throw a frisbee. And how in the world could those corporate whores not buy off Mother Nature & stop her from raining that night?!? My gosh, next time somebody else's money is throwing a party like that they should only be allowed to book sucky bands that will attract less than 200 people & not leave the field so muddy that the cute, fuzzy squirrels will get their tummies dirty when scampering across it. I will not stand for having our blades of grass desecrated at a time when nobody is using them, not to mention for the benefit of a good time and a great cause. Those blades of grass where here long before I became hyper-reactive about meaningless causes, and they should be here long after my bleeding heart becomes desensitized by this cruel, corporate run world!!! De asini vmbra disceptare

Posted by mandyAmanda at 1:50 PM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

I'm with Bob. Anyway I'm surprised all the dirty hippies aren't happy about this. They never shower and are filthy. I would have thought they like mud.

Posted by Bob at 5:15 AM on Nov 03, 2009 | Report this comment

This is so yesterday. Get over it. During the anti desert storm ralley that lasted for weeks, there were smelly college students and student wanna-be that occupied the medow and churned up the mud. VS said they pay for the damages. Grass does not grow over night. Oh and the students got a free concert.


Email

Your Name: *
Your Email: *  
To Email: *  
Subject: IDSnews.com | Mud, mud everywhere
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text



*