Vatican excommunicates 'illegitimate' Chinese bishops

VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican declared Thursday that two bishops ordained by China's state-controlled church without papal consent were excommunicated, escalating tensions as the two sides explored preliminary moves toward improving ties.\nThe Vatican also excommunicated the two bishops who ordained them, citing church law. The Holy See then criticized China for allegedly forcing bishops and priests to participate in "illegitimate" ordinations that "go against their conscience."\nPope Benedict XVI's first major diplomatic clash since being elected pontiff a year ago shatters hopes for any re-establishment soon of official ties that ended after communists took control of China in 1949.\nVatican spokesman Joaquin Navarro-Valls cited Article 1382 of the Roman Catholic Church's canon law in announcing the excommunications. That article states that "both the bishop who, without a pontifical mandate, consecrates a person a bishop, and the one who receives the consecration from him, incur a 'latae sententiae excommunication,'" which means they are excommunicated.\nEarlier, Navarro-Valls said Benedict was deeply saddened by news of the ordinations, which have occurred in recent weeks.\n"It is a great wound to the unity of the church," Navarro-Valls said in a statement.\nChinese Foreign Ministry officials were not available to comment on the excommunications. But earlier, when the Vatican had only denounced the ordinations, a duty officer referred to a statement issued Sunday after the first ordination.\n"The criticism toward the Chinese side by the Vatican is groundless," that statement said. "We hope the Vatican can respect the will of Chinese church and the vast numbers of priests as well as its church members so as to create good atmosphere for the improvement of Sino-Vatican ties."\nOn Wednesday, the official church, known as the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association, ordained Liu Xinhong as bishop at the city of Wuhu's St. Joseph's Church in the eastern province of Anhui.\nIt was the second ordination in three days without the consent of the Vatican, which traditionally appoints its own bishops. On Sunday, China's official church ordained Ma Yinglin as a bishop in the southwestern province of Yunnan.\nThe association has said the new appointments were meant to fill shortages and were not intended to offend the Vatican.\nThe Vatican statement said officials had received information indicating that "bishops and priests have been subjected -- by institutions not related to the church -- to strong pressures and threats, in order for them to take part in the ordinations that, because they were not approved by the Vatican, are illegitimate and go against their conscience."\n"We are therefore faced with a grave violation of religious freedom," Navarro-Valls said, adding the Vatican "had thought and hoped that such despicable events belonged to the past."\nThe ordinations come as China and the Holy See try to re-establish ties that ended after communists took control of China in 1949.\nFormal ties would give some security to Vatican loyalists in China, who are frequently harassed and fined and sometimes sent to labor camps. Most Chinese Catholics are only allowed to worship in government-controlled churches, but millions are loyal to the Vatican.\nBut the Vatican said any dialogue was at risk now.\n"The Holy See has in various occasions reiterated its willingness to have an honest and constructive dialogue with the competent Chinese authorities to find solutions that would satisfy the legitimate requirements of both sides," Navarro-Valls said.\n"Initiatives such as those mentioned above not only don't favor this dialogue, but instead create new obstacles against it."\nThe Holy See also expressed alarm at reports that 20 more bishops might be ordained without Vatican approval and stressed "the need for respect for freedom of the church and for the autonomy of its institutions from any external interference."\nIt added the Vatican "sincerely hopes that there will not be a repetition of these unacceptable acts of violence and inadmissible acts of coercion."\nIn the last high-profile case, the Vatican in 2002 excommunicated seven women -- including former Ohio first lady Dagmar Braun Celeste -- who participated in an ordination ceremony aboard a boat on the Danube River between Germany and Austria. The women called themselves priests.\nThat case was handled by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who led the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith before becoming pope last year.